Saturday, October 26, 2013

Fit to Be Tied

It has been ages since I've been able to write. Life plays such wicked tricks sometimes. We plan, God laughs. I've been talking to a lot of people these days about Polyamory, open relationships and the BDSM lifestyle.

I had this incredibly open conversation with a new friend who for the life of him could not understand how my wife could accept our lifestyle. He was convinced that I had blackmailed her into it our life together by saying "This is how I am and this is how we will be or we can't be a couple." He just wouldn't be convinced that she accepted our lifestyle because it interested her and because she loved me and understood me and desired that side of me. Sometimes young straight people can be so THICK! I eventually had to break it down to him and say "She's into it. It makes her hot." We were talking more about open relationships and not about BDSM. He still didn't get it.

The conversation had started around discussing Neil Strauss' The Game and why I would be reading that book or need social dynamic training to pick up women. The book simply fascinates me and I love Neil Strauss and the bibliography of the book. Of course people who Play in the BDSM community are totally different from the PUA community who feel they need to game the system to increase their success ratio. Don't get me wrong. I love the transformations of some pick up artists who are tired of being lonely and want to be able to create a connection with women. I just felt by the end of the book that there was something missing because they had no end game and had trouble finding the one woman they wanted to be with. There also wasn't a chapter on creating open relationships so that all parties were completely honest about how many people they were dating so that potentially they could still see each other and see other people.

I have a severe problem with pick up artists who just treat women like objects and treat them like crap because they are still pissed about how badly they were treated by men and women in high school and college before their self-transformation. But I digress.

My friend, after two hours of talking, still wasn't buying it. It didn't help that he was having a hard time finding one partner to share his life with let alone nine.

In a world where same sex marriage is becoming very mainstream I still feel very much in a closet of my own creation despite how many of my friends know about and accept my lifestyle. Professionally I feel the need to stay in a closet because my movement can barely handle the rabbis caught sleeping with a congregant other than their wife or husband. They are fully open to monogamous hetero or homosexual rabbis (as long as they are married to a Jewish partner), but haven't even begun dealing with the circle of rabbis in open or alternative relationships who are some of their most powerful and successful rabbis out there today. They can't understand that we succeed because we can relate to every person who comes into our office for counseling or conversation.

One of my partners on the West Coast sent me an incredible article from the Jewish Telegraphic Agency. Married and Dating. I was outraged by Rabbi Eliott Dorff's, the rector of American Jewish University in Los Angeles and a longtime champion of gay inclusion in the Jewish community, statement:
“First of all, the depth of the relationship is much greater if it’s monogamous,” Dorff said. “The chances that both partners are going to be able to fulfill all the obligations of a serious intimate relationship are much greater in a monogamous relationship. I would say the same to gay or straight couples: There should be one person you live your life with.”

I think he doesn't know what he's talking about. True, most people can't handle one fully actualized relationship let alone more than one. But he speaks of something he knows nothing about. I love each of my partners individually and differently. I am capable of expressing my love and devotion in completely different ways than I do with my primary partner. But I wouldn't still have a primary partner if my wife didn't feel my love, affection and devotion at her desired level. True I can't make her happy if she can't make herself happy. And conversely, she can't make me happy if I can't make myself happy. Any actualized person knows this. Our biggest issues are domestic. Raising the kids, cleaning the house and scheduling. Sexually we wish we had more time (who doesn't) but our open relationship and our BDSM proclivities don't hinder or lessen our love and devotion to each other and our ability to love and welcome other people into our lives. 

Dorff hasn't done any studies to prove that the depth of any relationship is much greater if it is monogamous (other than his own). He hasn't interviewed hundreds of poly or alt people to discover if his hypothesis is accurate. He is just throwing out his biased opinion based on his personal experience and what society has trained him to think without any accurate research or first hand experience. 

The choices I made to change how I lived and loved at 27 have allowed me room to re-open key relationships with old partners who accept me as I am now and my lifestyle. Their love, acceptance and place in my bed/dungeon have changed my life monumentally and made me a better primary partner in gratitude for the quantity of play and love in my life. I am more loving and more romantic at home than I ever would be if I was shut down and lived most of my romantic life in my mind rather than with the partners who make my life so rich.

I pray for the ability to someday have a congregation of poly and alt lifestyle people who are open to all expression of life, love and living (straight and gay monogamists are welcome too I guess). I want to be surrounded by Jews (all like-minded non-Jewish partners and those generally interested are welcome too of course) who are tolerant and accepting of all people and all lifestyles. There is no shame in living our own lives how we see fit to live them as long as everything we do is consensual among like-minded adults. Without us the world would be conformist and beige. No color, no rainbows, no excitement and really nothing to talk about. Be yourself we were always taught. Be proud of who you are. Love yourself in order to be able to love someone else. Shema Yisrael, Hear O' Israel, Adonai eloheinu, Adonai Echad, Adonai, Our God, Adonai is One. We are one. We have always been one. We've spent thousands of years getting back to being accepted for who we are and our oneness.

You are not alone. I am not alone. I love that you are all out there so that when I stand on my Bima, closeted from all my congregants who adore me, I know that I am not alone and that I am accepted for who I am somewhere out there.

Sunday, July 22, 2012

Finding Egypt


A lover of mine is African American
He likes to beat white women
It works for him
As it turns out, it works for me as well,
To be beaten by him.
We have a lovely relationship.
Phyiscal.  Full of need.  Full of desire.  Full of joy.
I wonder what it would be like
To have an Egyptian lover
To beat me like my ancestors did
To replay the story of my people
With a different ending
With pleasure instead of pain
Or at least pleasure combined with pain.
To celebrate the bondage of my communal history
In a new way
To bring me back to bondage
In order to celebrate my freedom
In a new way.
Would I want to slay my taskmaster like Moses
Did so long ago?
Or would I take what is given
Like a good girl
Treasuring each lash
Each strike
Feeling the pleasure through pain
Unable to explain it
Yet knowing it was there
Embracing it
Yearning for more.
You have made me in Your Image, God.
So you must have meant this for me, as well.
This need to have a part of me
Forever in Egypt
But finding my exodus from the land of enslavement
In slavery itself
Finding freedom through bondage
Escape through submission
The need to reach out through the need to obey
The need to honor that which is holy in myself
By discovering that which seems other
That which is mine alone
The bondage that my ancestors escaped
I redefine, and make my own
And that, too, is holy.

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Age is nothing but a number

Yeah, that's not true at all. Seriously, I haven't believed that for a long time....perhaps never, but age--in terms of how old a partner is--is something that's also, well, interesting.

I had a conversation with a vanilla friend earlier. Really, she's about as vanilla as they get. I've given her a few hints about my kink, but haven't had the full conversation. I don't think she'll be shocked when I do tell her, but I also don't think she's ever really considered that someone she knows enjoys the things that I enjoy...or looks for the kind of relationships that I seek. Anyway, she commented about someone she met that he was 29, and therefore too young for her...she's a few years younger than I am. I commented that I totally disagreed, and fully believe in the law of half your age plus 7. She came back that she really only considered her age plus 10 years, as she likes older men. I returned that I also like older men, and still consider younger men (within the rule)...and then the conversation turned to other topics. But it got me thinking about age.

I like older men. Always have. When I was 22, I was with a man twice my age. More recently, I've been with men whose children I was closer in age to than he was. Looking at every man I've been with, in any way, since my first kiss at age 10, actually...I think there are maybe 5 guys that were younger than I was. And I wonder why that is.

I mean, I sometimes joke that I have the sex drive of a teenaged boy. I know that I'm at or near my prime, and that men reach their peak at a younger age. Maybe I should be thinking about someone younger...I mean, I've been with guys who are at the age where Viagra becomes commonplace. And that doesn't bother me...but, then again, I often want more than they do. Logically, I should be thinking about younger men.

I suppose part of it is the whole sub thing...I look to older men because perhaps they can give me more guidance, perhaps. But I think I'm also just attracted to them. In some ways, I think a younger guy could be fun...but could I submit to them for long? True submission is hard enough for me (as in truly letting go with my mind, fully)...maybe I'm reticent to fully trust someone who is younger. Or maybe I like the idea of someone with more life experience than I have.

Or maybe it's something entirely different. Maybe it's just that I like older men. I'm not sure.

But it's on my mind at the moment...so I figured I'd offer it up here. What do you all think about age? Is there something to be said for someone older? Someone younger?

Friday, April 22, 2011

Happy blogoversary

OK...it's been a bit over a year, but we missed the year mark, so be it.

It struck me earlier that it had been about a year since we started this little blog, and took a moment to look back at when we really did start...and doing a bit of rereading of our posts...what a year it's been.

This was my second Pesach since admitting this discovery to myself, and starting to admit it to others...again, all that talk of bondage at the seder made me smile internally a few times. And this time around, I took the opportunity to come out as kinky to 2 of my close friends. They both took it so nonchanantly...so in stride. It made me thankful to have wonderful friends. And helped me to feel a little bit more, well, normal.

So much else has happened in my own life in the past year. I started writing more, my grandfather died, LOST ended, I started a new job after a long time being severely underemployed, I moved, I had a few non-starter BDSM relationships, 1 really bad one, 1 potentially great one that we both realized wasn't able to be that which we had dreamed it could be (that kind of broke my heart--the fact it wasn't to be, not him--he was wonderful and still is. It was the right thing to end where we were...and I'm thankful every day for his ongoing friendship), a bit of fun play here and there, and a good dose of potential that's only just beginning. I tried things that I never imagined I'd dare try, and even enjoyed some of them. And I keep my eye out for more exploration in that realm...and in life.

May this be a year of new experiences, new lessons, new ideas for us all.

I'm babbling, I realize. But I want to get back to what a year this has been. And how we started around Pesach last year (I do believe it was during Pesach that Spritually Playful learned about my proclivities, Rabbi Submissive knowing for longer. She was the first person I told of my exploration, as she was the one who helped me take the first steps), and how so much of this is about freedom. We named this blog for a reason...and it is through our recognition that returning to bondage, by choice, gives us so much of the freedom we all seek.

As we enter this Shabbat of Pesach, I hope that we all find the peace--the shleimut--that comes from acceptance of who we are. Of what we are becoming in the constant process of life.

And that we all find others who help us to complete that journey.

Shabbat Shalom and Chag Sameach!!

Monday, April 4, 2011

A Tale of 2 Cities

With CCAR convention in NOLA & the RA in Vegas, this week's theme is "Your rabbi is having more fun than you are."

Not quite fair to say that this tweet went viral, but within a really small segment of the Jewish world (even smaller segment of the world at large), this statement was shared by and amused more than a few people. And, it's true. Last week, The Rabbinical Assembly and Central Conference of American Rabbis each met in Las Vegas and New Orleans, respectively. Yes, the Conservative and Reform rabbis each had their annual conventions in the 2 US cities perhaps most known for debauchery.

Of course, there is more to a conference than the city where it was held. I was at one of them, and can attest to that. I've read reports from the other and it sounds like the 2 conventions were similar. Both movements discussed the goings on in Israel and the Middle East at large, considered technology and how it fits in to what we do, pondered how to move beyond what it is we do in order to reach those that we don't and began to envision the future of our movements. We learned, we prayed, we networked, we shared. We inspired and were inspired by our fellow colleagues. We socialized with old friends and found new connections. Our conventions are about all of these things and this was true once again, in both cases.

But I think there is something to be said...to be thought about...regarding the location of both conventions this year. Yes, there were the jokes. And yes, there were many comments about what we weren't doing (perhaps the rabbis doth protest too much?). I have to wonder about how honest those comments were. To what extent did we partake in that which the city we were visiting had to offer?

I admit here that I went to a strip club with a few colleagues. It was fun and instructive on a number of levels. But I also share that we looked both ways before we exited; and were very careful about who knew our whereabouts. I have to wonder how many others did the same....or went down their own paths of exploration. Both groups being in cities where anonymity is part of what happens naturally...where it's so easy to hide....here there are so many venues for behavior that might be perceived as "not what we do" (even if some of us know it's exactly what we love to do). There must have been more that went on...or at least temptation. I highly doubt that the 3 people I went to the strip club with were the only other colleagues that partook in all the city had to offer.

I have to believe that at my convention and at the other that the 4 of us were not the only ones that did something outside the perceived boundaries of what we are "supposed to" do. I know there are others who are kinky...who think outside the box about matters of sexuality. How many were aware enough of their needs to partake? How many felt the freedom to explore, even if just a little.

In some ways, those of us who are still in the closet, but have begun to peek out, owe both groups of conference planners a load of thanks. For giving us the opportunity to convene with like minded colleagues who allow us to explore--to put us in locales where such exploration is bound to happen. Perhaps that's not what the planners had considered as goals...but I think it's a good thing. It's all part of finding the right balance between all the aspects of our lives.

I, for one, am thankful that I had the chance to explore this locale...this aspect of my self...with colleagues that I know I'm lucky to have.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

And Haman Was His Name-O

I actually hate that song, for the record. But it is, admittedly, catchy. I'm exhausted from working Purim (a holiday that's still such fun, but a lot more tiring when you're on the organizing end of Jewish life), but I wanted to expand on my last post. My thoughts are still not entirely formed, but I've thought about this over the past week, and I do want to share along the way. So here are a few thoughts on considering the Book of Esther, the story of Purim, through the lens of BDSM.

First off, the theme of costuming ourselves--wearing masks. On a basic level, this invokes images of the accouterments of the fetish scene--the leather and latex, if that's your thing...or even just what we choose to wear for our partner, to evoke the message we want to send--from whatever end we're coming from. And, for some of us, it's about the way we hide who we are because we have this aspect of ourselves. For the most part, I hide my kink from the world at large...and I hide the fact I'm a rabbi when I'm in kink-realm. In this way, I can relate to Esther...not wanting to let others know who she truly was....not being able to let her true self show, entirely.

And we have these wonderful, erotic pieces of the text. For someone into submission, all this talk of bowing can evoke a certain feeling. And, that whole not-a-fashion-show contest King A (I hate trying to spell his name) holds to choose a new queen. And what is, perhaps, the statement most full of innuendo in of biblical literature, Esther 4:2 (old JPS translation): "And it was so, when the king saw Esther the queen standing in the court, that she obtained favour in his sight; and the king held out to Esther the golden sceptre that was in his hand. So Esther drew near, and touched the top of the sceptre." Ummmm...really?

And then we have these character archetypes, as I'm coming to see them.

Vashti: the sub who is well aware of her power and isn't afraid to be herself. As I said, I love Vashti in a lot of ways. The gal sticks up for herself. She is her own person and does what she needs to. I think she's gotten a bum rap from Judaism in general...I admire her, in many ways, more than I like Esther (who kind of seems kind of whiney, imho. And too willing to be led, in some ways.). Seems odd, from a sub perspective, I suppose. But, at the same time, she knows her limits--and once they're crossed, she's not going to let that happen. She knows what she wants in a D-type and isn't going to submit to one she doesn't want to submit to.

King A also comes off as the quintessential Dim Dom...the guy wants everyone to answer to him...and never seems particularly bright. And once he throws one gal away (because she wasn't twue enough), he tests out new models until he finds a new one. And then he falls for her...and pretty much lets himself be manipulated by everyone, despite the fact that he's still the one apparently in charge.

Still figuring out Haman and Esther and Mordechai. I guess Mord would be the helpful, supportive vanilla friend, who helpfully pushes those of us not-so-vanilla towards being whom we need to be. Haman, maybe, the overconfident sadist who knows what power he holds, but doesn't take all of reality (and what he might not know) into consideration--he acts as a Dominant, but isn't truly Dominant at his core.

And Esther, well, I don't really know. The newbie, perhaps? Taking others advice...scared of everything, it seems...willing to be pushed but, ultimately, willing to take care of what she needs to.

I've often wondered why Purim was such a kid-focused holiday. I mean, yeah--costumes are fun, and who doesn't like a good carnival. But when you look at it, I think we miss out on a lot. The drunken debauchery on the one hand...and the sexy nature of the story in general (even if not reading it as we might). The Book of Esther is a very adult story...I think it's a good thing for us to start thinking of it that way.

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Oh Once There Was a Wicked, Wicked Man

Wow, We've been remiss. Sorry!

Teaching Purim today, I started to realize how much this story has to say about BDSM. I mean, really. It's all about submission in a lot of ways...from Vashti refusing the king's command (love her as a feminist role model, btw) to Mordechai refusing to bow to Haman to Achashveros' competitive orgy (let's not pretend it was a beauty contest)....

I have more to say about this, but I welcome your comments as I process. But, really...going through the tale today, it really struck me.